Australian Lawyers for Human Rights (ALHR) is a network of Australian lawyers active in practising and promoting awareness of international human rights standards in Australia.
If you are qualified to practice as a legal practitioner in Australia, or are studying or teaching law in Australia, or are working in a legal capacity in Australia, please consider joining us.
Read about us and our activities, from the menu above.
28/11/2009 ALHR Members: Urgent action required
As you know the federal government is currently considering its response to the Brennan Committee report and that there
has been extensive discussion within the ALP caucus and some consideration by Ministers.
We have been told that a number of organisations opposed to a human rights act have been
inundating their local members with emails. We are particularly concerned that a number of conservative religious groups are stating that churches and faith based groups oppose the enactment of a human rights act. We know that is not the case and that there are many faith based groups in favour of a human rights act.
We are asking you to help counter this misinformation by writing to your local MP or Senator
immediately stating your support for a human rights act. If you have a mailing list or a number of members then please forward this email to them.
Here are some main points you could include in your email or letter:
The Brennan report records overwhelming community support for a human rights act. 87% of submissions were in favour,
and the polling reveals 57% in support and only 13% against. Other research, especially Amnesty International's, affirms that most Australians want their basic rights protected in law.
Brennan's proposal for an act covering civil and political rights would apply to the Commonwealth
and its agencies. It would not apply to NGOs, churches or other organisations outside the Commonwealth.
If the parliament wished a law to override the human rights act, that decision would need to be made
explicit. The High Court could otherwise find that an action of the Commonwealth was inconsistent with the human rights act. Parliament would then reconsider the matter but the court could not change or strike down inconsistent laws.
ALHR supports the Brennan approach because it would change for the better the way the bureaucracy
deals with vulnerable people. It would require greater and more consistent focus by the parliament on human rights.
Opponents claim that the Brennan proposal would interfere with church employment practices.
As churches are not to be covered by the act, this claim is wrong.
Many church bodies support an act and made public submissions to that effect:
the Uniting Church , the National Anglican Synod, the St Vincent de Paul Society, and the Sisters of Mercy among others. Cardinal Pell's opposition to an act was not the position taken by the Australian Bishops Conference (which was neutral)
It is vital that all MPs receive messages now that support implementation of the Brennan report,
and point out the groundless nature of the fears being expressed.
Materials, including a Briefing Paper on a Human Rights Act, a summary of the report's key findings
and recommendations, and the HRLRC submissions to the Consultation, are available at: http://www.hrlrc.org.au/content/topics/national-human-rights-consultation/act-now-a-human-rights-act-for-australia/
Please send messages, by email, fax, phone or in person, in support of a human rights act to your local MP or Senator.
Here is an online list of MPs: List of Members, Vol 72, 16 November 2009 http://www.aph.gov.au/house/members/memlist.pdf
Here is an online list of Senators Senators' Parliament House and State/Territory addresses, phone and fax numbers http://www.aph.gov.au/Senate/senators/contacts/los.htm
Or fill out a "Contact Form" with your comment to the following MPs.
Adelaide, SA Ellis, The Hon Kate, Member for Adelaide
Aston, Vic Pearce, The Hon Chris, Member for Aston
Ballarat, Vic King, Ms Catherine, Member for Ballarat
Banks, NSW Melham, Mr Daryl, Member for Banks
Barker, SA Secker, Mr Patrick, Member for Barker
Barton, NSW McClelland, The Hon Robert, Member for Barton
Bass, Tas Campbell, Ms Jodie, Member for Bass
Batman, Vic Ferguson, The Hon Martin, Member for Batman
Bendigo, Vic Gibbons, Mr Steve, Member for Bendigo
Bennelong, NSW McKew, The Hon Maxine, Member for Bennelong
Berowra, NSW Ruddock, The Hon Philip, Member for Berowra
Blair, Qld Neumann, Mr Shayne, Member for Blair
Blaxland, NSW Clare, The Hon Jason, Member for Blaxland
Bonner, Qld Rea, Ms Kerry, Member for Bonner
Boothby, SA Southcott, Dr Andrew, Member for Boothby
Bowman, Qld Laming, Mr Andrew, Member for Bowman
Braddon, Tas Sidebottom, Mr Sid, Member for Braddon
Bradfield, NSW Vacant - a by-election is to be held on Saturday, 5 December 2009. See the Australian Electoral Commission website for more information.
Brand, WA Gray, The Hon Gary, Member for Brand
Brisbane, Qld Bevis, The Hon Arch, Member for Brisbane
Bruce, Vic Griffin, The Hon Alan, Member for Bruce
Calare, NSW Cobb, The Hon John, Member for Calare
Calwell, Vic Vamvakinou, Ms Maria, Member for Calwell
Canberra, ACT Ellis, Ms Annette, Member for Canberra
Canning, WA Randall, Mr Don, Member for Canning
Capricornia, Qld Livermore, Ms Kirsten, Member for Capricornia
Casey, Vic Smith, The Hon Tony, Member for Casey
Charlton, NSW Combet, The Hon Greg, Member for Charlton
Chifley, NSW Price, The Hon Roger, Member for Chifley
Chisholm, Vic Burke, Ms Anna, Member for Chisholm
Cook, NSW Morrison, Mr Scott, Member for Cook
Corangamite, Vic Cheeseman, Mr Darren, Member for Corangamite
Corio, Vic Marles, The Hon Richard, Member for Corio
Cowan, WA Simpkins, Mr Luke, Member for Cowan
Cowper, NSW Hartsuyker, Mr Luke, Member for Cowper
Cunningham, NSW Bird, Ms Sharon, Member for Cunningham
Curtin, WA Bishop, The Hon Julie, Member for Curtin
Dawson, Qld Bidgood, Mr James, Member for Dawson
Deakin, Vic Symon, Mr Mike, Member for Deakin
Denison, Tas Kerr, The Hon Duncan, Member for Denison
Dickson, Qld Dutton, The Hon Peter, Member for Dickson
Dobell, NSW Thomson, Mr Craig, Member for Dobell
Dunkley, Vic Billson, The Hon Bruce, Member for Dunkley
Eden-Monaro, NSW Kelly, The Hon Dr Mike, Member for Eden-Monaro
Fadden, Qld Robert, Mr Stuart, Member for Fadden
Fairfax, Qld Somlyay, The Hon Alexander, Member for Fairfax
Farrer, NSW Ley, The Hon Sussan, Member for Farrer
Fisher, Qld Slipper, The Hon Peter, Member for Fisher
Flinders, Vic Hunt, The Hon Greg, Member for Flinders
Flynn, Qld Trevor, Mr Chris, Member for Flynn
Forde, Qld Raguse, Mr Brett, Member for Forde
Forrest, WA Marino, Ms Nola, Member for Forrest
Fowler, NSW Irwin, Mrs Julia, Member for Fowler
Franklin, Tas Collins, Ms Julie, Member for Franklin
Fraser, ACT McMullan, Mr Bob, Member for Fraser
Fremantle, WA Parke, Ms Melissa, Member for Fremantle
Gellibrand, Vic Roxon, The Hon Nicola, Member for Gellibrand
Gilmore, NSW Gash, Mrs Joanna, Member for Gilmore
Gippsland, Vic Chester, Mr Darren, Member for Gippsland
Goldstein, Vic Robb, The Hon Andrew, Member for Goldstein
Gorton, Vic O'Connor, The Hon Brendan, Member for Gorton
Grayndler, NSW Albanese, The Hon Anthony, Member for Grayndler
Greenway, NSW Markus, Mrs Louise, Member for Greenway
Grey, SA Ramsey, Mr Rowan, Member for Grey
Griffith, Qld Rudd, The Hon Kevin, Member for Griffith
Groom, Qld Macfarlane, The Hon Ian, Member for Groom
Hasluck, WA Jackson, Ms Sharryn, Member for Hasluck
Herbert, Qld Lindsay, The Hon Peter, Member for Herbert
Higgins, Vic Vacant - a by-election is to be held on Saturday, 5 December 2009. See the Australian Electoral Commission website for more information.
Hindmarsh, SA Georganas, Mr Steve, Member for Hindmarsh
Hinkler, Qld Neville, Mr Paul, Member for Hinkler
Holt, Vic Byrne, The Hon Anthony, Member for Holt
Hotham, Vic Crean, The Hon Simon, Member for Hotham
Hughes, NSW Vale, The Hon Danna, Member for Hughes
Hume, NSW Schultz, Mr Alby, Member for Hume
Hunter, NSW Fitzgibbon, The Hon Joel, Member for Hunter
Indi, Vic Mirabella, Mrs Sophie, Member for Indi
Isaacs, Vic Dreyfus, Mr Mark, Member for Isaacs
Jagajaga, Vic Macklin, The Hon Jenny, Member for Jagajaga
Kalgoorlie, WA Haase, Mr Barry, Member for Kalgoorlie
Kennedy, Qld Katter, The Hon Bob, Member for Kennedy
Kingsford Smith, NSW Garrett, The Hon Peter, Member for Kingsford Smith
Kingston, SA Rishworth, Ms Amanda, Member for Kingston
Kooyong, Vic Georgiou, Mr Petro, Member for Kooyong
La Trobe, Vic Wood, Mr Jason, Member for La Trobe
Lalor, Vic Gillard, The Hon Julia, Member for Lalor
Leichhardt, Qld Turnour, Mr Jim, Member for Leichhardt
Lilley, Qld Swan, The Hon Wayne, Member for Lilley
Lindsay, NSW Bradbury, Mr David, Member for Lindsay
Lingiari, NT Snowdon , The Hon Warren, Member for Lingiari
Longman, Qld Sullivan, Mr Jon, Member for Longman
Lowe, NSW Murphy, The Hon John, Member for Lowe
Lyne, NSW Oakeshott, Mr Robert, Member for Lyne
Lyons, Tas Adams, The Hon Dick, Member for Lyons
Macarthur, NSW Farmer, The Hon Pat, Member for Macarthur
Mackellar, NSW Bishop, The Hon Bronwyn, Member for Mackellar
Macquarie, NSW Debus, The Hon Bob, Member for Macquarie
Makin, SA Zappia, Mr Tony, Member for Makin
Mallee, Vic Forrest, Mr John, Member for Mallee
Maranoa, Qld Scott, The Hon Bruce, Member for Maranoa
Maribyrnong, Vic Shorten, The Hon Bill, Member for Maribyrnong
Mayo, SA Briggs, Mr Jamie, Member for Mayo
McEwen, Vic Bailey, The Hon Fran, Member for McEwen
McMillan, Vic Broadbent, Mr Russell, Member for McMillan
McPherson, Qld May, Mrs Margaret, Member for McPherson
Melbourne, Vic Tanner, The Hon Lindsay, Member for Melbourne
Melbourne Ports, Vic Danby, Mr Michael, Member for Melbourne Ports
Menzies, Vic Andrews, The Hon Kevin, Member for Menzies
Mitchell, NSW Hawke, Mr Alex, Member for Mitchell
Moncrieff, Qld Ciobo, Mr Steven, Member for Moncrieff
Moore, WA Washer, Dr Mal, Member for Moore
Moreton, Qld Perrett, Mr Graham, Member for Moreton
Murray, Vic Stone, The Hon Dr Sharman, Member for Murray
New England, NSW Windsor , Mr Tony, Member for New England
Newcastle, NSW Grierson, Ms Sharon, Member for Newcastle
North Sydney, NSW Hockey, The Hon Joe, Member for North Sydney
O'Connor, WA Tuckey, The Hon Wilson, Member for O'Connor
Oxley, Qld Ripoll, Mr Bernie, Member for Oxley
Page, NSW Saffin, Ms Janelle, Member for Page
Parkes, NSW Coulton, Mr Mark, Member for Parkes
Parramatta, NSW Owens, Ms Julie, Member for Parramatta
Paterson, NSW Baldwin, The Hon Bob, Member for Paterson
Pearce, WA Moylan, The Hon Judi, Member for Pearce
Perth, WA Smith, The Hon Stephen, Member for Perth
Petrie, Qld D'Ath, Mrs Yvette, Member for Petrie
Port Adelaide, SA Butler , The Hon Mark, Member for Port Adelaide
Prospect, NSW Bowen, The Hon Chris, Member for Prospect
Rankin, Qld Emerson, The Hon Dr Craig, Member for Rankin
Reid, NSW Ferguson , The Hon Laurie, Member for Reid
Richmond, NSW Elliot, The Hon Justine, Member for Richmond
Riverina, NSW Hull , Mrs Kay, Member for Riverina
Robertson, NSW Neal, Ms Belinda, Member for Robertson
Ryan, Qld Johnson, Mr Michael, Member for Ryan
Scullin, Vic Jenkins, Mr Harry, Member for Scullin
Shortland, NSW Hall, Ms Jill, Member for Shortland
Solomon, NT Hale, Mr Damian, Member for Solomon
Stirling, WA Keenan, Mr Michael, Member for Stirling
Sturt, SA Pyne, The Hon Christopher, Member for Sturt
Swan, WA Irons, Mr Steve, Member for Swan
Sydney, NSW Plibersek, The Hon Tanya, Member for Sydney
Tangney, WA Jensen, Dr Dennis, Member for Tangney
Throsby, NSW George, Ms Jennie, Member for Throsby
Wakefield, SA Champion, Mr Nick, Member for Wakefield
Wannon, Vic Hawker, The Hon David, Member for Wannon
Warringah, NSW Abbott, The Hon Tony, Member for Warringah
Watson, NSW Burke, The Hon Tony, Member for Watson
Wentworth, NSW Turnbull, The Hon Malcolm, Member for Wentworth
Werriwa, NSW Hayes, Mr Chris, Member for Werriwa
Wide Bay, Qld Truss, The Hon Warren, Member for Wide Bay
Wills, Vic Thomson, Mr Kelvin, Member for Wills
Other ways to look for your local MP: see http://www.aph.gov.au/house/members/index.htm